Nominated for Best New Political Blog of 2009

Weblogawards.Org

Showing posts with label World Trade Center. Show all posts
Showing posts with label World Trade Center. Show all posts

Thursday, November 19, 2009

The Trial of Khalid Sheikh Momhammed

On November 13, 2009, the U.S. Justice Department announced that it will be transferring five of the Guantanamo Bay detainees to New York to face trial for their involvement in the September 11, 2001 attacks involving the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.

Despite a public outcry against this strategy, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, Ramzi Bin al-Shibh, Walid bin Attash, Ali Abdul Aziz Ali and Mustafa Ahmed al-Hawsawi are to be tried in Federal Court literally blocks from the scarred hole in the ground where the Twin Towers once stood. Recent polls show that Americans oppose trying terror suspects in the Federal court system by a margin of two to one but that has not deterred Obama administration Attorney General, Eric Holder, who claims that the day has finally arrived for these men to face justice.

After a brief statement, Eric Holder faced harsh questioning in the Senate yesterday and was visibly unprepared for the direction the questioning had taken. Senator Lindsay Graham asked Holder “Can you give me a case in United States history when an enemy combatant caught on a battlefield was tried in civilian court?” As Mr. Holder struggled to find an appropriate answer he finally uttered that he would have to research the issue at which time, Senator Graham interrupted and answered the question for him. “The answer is never” Graham said, adding “We are making bad history”’.

Senator Graham was not being deliberately argumentative; he was stating a point of law that could spell doom for the prosecution of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and his four coconspirators. If you try these individuals in Federal Court you must bestow the full protection of the American legal system on the defendants; protections that would thwart the ability of the United States to gather intelligence from captured terrorists crucial to the efforts of this nation protect itself against future attacks. Mr. Holder could not answer the question of whether or not these defendants were advised of their Miranda rights or if they had ever been offered legal council, both of which are fundamental to any civil prosecution.

If Mohammed had not been advised of his rights or given the opportunity to seek counsel, the statements he made regarding his involvement in the attacks would be inadmissible in civilian court. The detainees were captured by the military in a foreign country during the prosecution of a war so reasonably, they had not been “Mirandized” when taken into custody nor had they been offered an attorney prior to questioning, both of which are required by our system of justice. We already know that the CIA engaged in water-boarding the detainees to obtain additional intelligence and whether you agree with that practice or not, the information it yielded has kept us from feeling the sting of additional civilian attacks on American soil since 9/11. As beneficial as that information was, the methods simply will not fly in a civilian court.

The primary question that any first year law student would present in the defense of these individuals would revolve around the Constitutional protections against torture, self incrimination, the right to legal counsel and since he was captured in 2003, the right to a speedy trial. They would not be wrong, that is how our system of justice protects American’s from potential abuses of the authorities. Unfortunately, we do not have a separate set of rules for the prosecution of foreign combatants or extremist terrorists. If we intend to prosecute them in the United States criminal justice system then those same protections would have to be afforded to the terrorists. There are already recorded statutory cases where the Supreme Court have overturned convictions and freed known criminals because their civil rights had been violated. The Supreme Court did not free these individuals because the violation of their rights brought the evidence against them into question, they were guilty men freed in essence, only because their constitutional rights had been violated.

Knowing what we know, can anyone argue that even if the courts were to ignore these facts and allow the trial to proceed at all, that the Supreme Court would have to review the conviction on appeal and would most likely free these men because their civil rights had been violated during their apprehension and incarceration? That is the law and that is why we do not try these cases in civil court. These are foreign combatants that launched an attack against the United States in effect, declaring war on America. Their trial is a military matter and does not belong in the civilian courts nor do they deserve to be afforded the same constitutional rights guaranteed by an America they are pledged to destroy.

One of the most disturbing things about this is the number of stories I have seen coming from the press calling the transfer of these prisoners to New York “foolish” or indicative of the administration’s inexperience. As usual, I have a very different take on this. Eric Holder is an exceptionally bright individual. He had begun working for the Justice Department upon completion of law school before serving as a judge for the Superior Court of the District of Columbia. In 1993, Holder was appointed to the post of U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia and eventually became the Deputy Attorney General under Bill Clinton. This man knows the law and I am sure he knows the precedents of Supreme Court decisions regarding prisoners whose civil rights had been violated. If he doesn’t, you can be certain his staff does. In light of his experience and knowledge of the law, why would Eric Holder attempt to prosecute Khalid Sheikh Mohammed in civilian courts if he knows that a conviction cannot stand a Supreme Court challenge?

This administration has been locked in battle to advance their radical agenda ever since Barack Obama has taken the oath of office. They had counted on the complacency if the American people but the recession had turned the spotlight on and the people have been waiting for some sign from this President that he is going to take meaningful steps to restore the vitality of the economy. The President pressed for immediate passage of a $787 billion dollar stimulus bill claiming that passage of this bill would stem the recession and reduce unemployment. We watched as the administration spoke glowingly of how well the stimulus plan was working while each month an additional 200,000 plus people lost their jobs.

Instead of focusing on the economy, we watched the administration campaign for an energy bill (cap and trade) that promises to further cripple business in this country and to hobble the economy. After Cap and Trade was passed through the House of Representatives, Healthcare reform became the priority for Obama and we watched the House churn out a massive one-thousand page bill and press for a vote before the members of Congress had even had an opportunity to read it. As the details of healthcare bill were revealed, people took to the streets and attended town hall meetings to protest against this crazy jumble of taxes and mandates in an attempt to bring attention to what American’s really want…jobs and a stable economy. People recognize that America can not survive if we continue the growth of the Federal Debt but the government keeps writing massive spending bills.

Now we are faced with the sad fact that the Government has absolutely no idea where hundreds of billions in stimulus money has been spent. The eighteen-million dollar website dedicated to tracking the stimulus money and the jobs it has created has been an unqualified disaster. The site shows jobs created through millions spent in Congressional districts that do not exist. The media’s examination of the figures shows not just a trend, but a systematic exaggeration of the jobs that have been attributed to stimulus money. Despite this expose’, the administration is still applauding the success of the stimulus bill even as unemployment topped 10.2%.

The President is also struggling with an image he has created of an inexperienced Commander in Chief that is unable to take decisive action even when his hand-picked theater commander in Afghanistan tells him he needs to reinforce the troop levels in the Afghan war or face the failure of the mission. The request made by General McChrystal in mid-September is still under consideration and that does not bode well with the people that heard Candidate Obama say that he would heed the advice of his generals and give them the materials and support they need to succeed in their mission.

Anyone that has ever been on stage know that spotlights can get awfully hot; heat this President didn’t expect. When faced with the possible loss of both healthcare and cap and trade they had only one course left….blame Bush. The public trials of Mohammed and his friends are meant to shift the spotlight from this administration and on to the so-called “atrocities” committed against the people detained in Guantanamo Bay. After all, what would bring Bush’s name back into focus better than months of testimony about the poor treatment these people received at the hands of the Army and the CIA? Well, that was another miscalculation on the part of Obama and his crew.

Americans have not forgotten the burning buildings or the innocent Americans leaping to their deaths to escape the flames. They have not forgotten that the “accused” was not only responsible for the 2001 attacks on the Twin Towers and the Pentagon but also the 1993 attack on the World Trade Center, the attempted airliner “shoe bombing” by Richard Reid, the bombing of nightclubs in Bali where Americans frequently relaxed and Mohammed has even admitted that he was in fact, the individual that beheaded American Journalist, Daniel Pearl.

We are a compassionate nation but we have no stomach for barbarians that practice the slaughter of innocent people. This is not an enemy that is really seeking retribution for perceived ills. This is an enemy that hates us for who we are. His actions are not meant to convert people to his religion but rather to eliminate them entirely. Even the Spanish Inquisition’s ultimate goal was to secure the salvation of man and to spread the word of God, not to indiscriminately kill anyone that did not already possess a bible.

If the Justice Department insists that these men are tried in civilian courts and they are freed on a technicality, the spirits of the people murdered by this fanatic will scream aloud and their voices will be heard every remaining day of Obama’s single and inglorious term as President.

Paul

Friday, September 11, 2009

In Memory of September 11, 2001


We Will Never Forget

Do you remember those words? Do you remember the flags and the ceremonies? Do you remember a nation joined in tragedy?

Living in Arizona, it was still early when the radio announced that a commuter plane had struck one of the towers of the World Trade Center. Since I had originally come from New York, I immediately turned the television on just in time to see the second plane hit. It may have taken the news commentators by surprise, and they did need a few minutes to recover, but in that instant I knew there was only one possible answer. We were under attack by terrorists. Shortly after that, the Pentagon was hit and another plane had crashed in the fields of Pennsylvania as a group of heroic passengers sacrificed themselves in an effort to save the next intended target.

Over the next few days we watched the efforts to find anyone alive in that tangled smoking mess. We saw the tears of family members desperately searching for their loved ones. We saw the City of New York mourn for the firefighters and police that perished in their attempt to rescue those that were trapped in the still burning towers. Within hours, we knew there would be no more survivors beyond the few that were miraculously protected in the cocoon of a reinforced stairwell. A nation wept as the memorial services were held across the United States and we watched that too.

I saw the signs that said “We will never forget” and made a prediction that sadly came true before a year had even passed. I had hoped against hope that this time, the people really wouldn't forget and while some still remember, there are even more that have chosen to let other priorities overshadow the memory of that day. I knew they eventually would because patriotism is an inconvenience that modern man has little time for.

Hundreds of thousands of our finest soldiers bravely left the shores of this nation to bring retribution to the people that attacked the United States on September 11th. As usual, we brought the fight to them so that our people could be spared the hardships and horrors of war. Our families were safe and the stories of the lighting speed at which our military exacted the revenge of an angry America was unheard of in the annals of history. We cheered and waved our flags and then left for work. While our soldiers slept in ditches and fought in the foul stench of war we sipped our coffee and watched it all on television like some surreal reality show.

Day after day we went to work, walked our dogs, and played with our kids; slowly the country slipped back into the daily routines and that made us believe we were comfortable and safe again. I’m not sure when it began, but slowly the extra security at the airports became a cause to grumble. We didn’t like the inconvenience of new restrictions on mailing packages or for carry on luggage. The news agencies dropped their flags once more and began to run their usual liberal speak about the unfair profiling used during security checks and the mounting death toll incurred in the two wars we were then engaged in. Not one thought was given to the families that lost loved ones on September 11, 2001 as their stories in as much as said those losses were not worth the “atrocities” being committed by this nation for our revenge.

I suppose the most disconcerting thing is that I am talking about the main stream media and their following of "socially conscious" celebrities. I would expect this from the cadre of conspiracy clowns that believed that 9/11 was perpetrated by the Bush administration to give him the moral authority to start a war in the Middle East; ok, I actually expected it from Hollywood too. Then again, nothing that comes from tinsel town surprises me, but CNN? CBS? NBC? ABC?

I do want to set the record straight. I do not believe that we should have allowed President Bush to tear loopholes in the Constitution in the form of the Patriot Act. We already had the legal processes in place to put people under surveillance if there was sufficient proof to bring before a judge. In fact, if the CIA had only shared what they already knew with the FBI instead of engaging in a petty fight over jurisdiction, 9/11 may well have been prevented.

While I believe that Bush had the best interest of the country at heart, I think the Patriot act set a dangerous precedent that will allow future Presidents (or our current President) the ability to spy on the citizens of this country at will and that is probably why Janet Napolitano has come up with a very interesting profile of what domestic terrorists look like. Hmmm….I guess it’s ok to profile at least some Americans now.

I do not think the United States has any business engaging in “Nation Building”. If we are threatened with attack then we should by all means neutralize that threat and then leave. If the United States had the reputation of dealing swift and brutal reprisals that were not accompanied by billions of dollars to rebuild what we just spent billions of dollars to destroy, who would dare test us? How often would they try? But no, we place our military in danger by taking away their most effective weapons and turn them into policemen; a job they were never trained to perform while palates of cash are flown in to restore foreign infrastructure while ours at home is sadly crumbling.

Our nation was attacked in 2001 by foreign terrorists residing in the United States. Why then, are we still discussing illegal immigration in 2009? While the Patriot Act allowed the Federal government unprecedented freedom to gather intelligence on the citizens of this country, our borders remained curiously open and the rudimentary steps to identify potential terrorists were never taken.

Step one? Anyone here on a Visa should have been required to report to the State Department immediately for verification of their identity and whereabouts. Those that failed to report should have automatically been considered suspect and sought out.

Step two? Our borders and other points of international entry should have been closely guarded. Here in Arizona, we are constantly finding the remnants of tunnels excavated by mere drug traffickers, the complexity of which defy logic. How can this happen in a post-9/11 America? Where is the vigilance? Where are the Federal authorities that are pledged to defend this nation?

Step three? When you are dealing with foreign extremists that are pledged to kill as many Americans as humanly possible, there is no such thing as profiling. The idea that an eighty-year old woman had to be frightened out of her wits as she was hand searched before boarding an airplane is ludicrous. To my knowledge, there were no eighty year old women that participated in the hijackings of September 11th. Yet, I saw this lunacy myself as I was passing through security at Sky Harbor Airport in November of 2001. The only reason airport security had even questioned this woman was to prevent ABC, NBC, CBS, CNN and the like, from airing more stories that airport authorities were racially profiling passengers if and when they searched someone of middle-eastern heritage.

Today is September 11, 2009, the eighth anniversary of the attacks and across the nation, people will take their flags out of mothballs and the news networks will surrender three minutes of air time to cover the memorial services so we can all say “I remember”. Then the sun will set and the sun will rise and people will wake up, sip their coffee and walk their dogs again while our soldiers are still sleeping in ditches in a hostile land. The real difference is that today we have a President that would dare to politicize this solemn day by once again, infusing his agenda into the memorial ceremonies by calling for a "National Day of Service and Remembrance." Only a narcissist would place their own message of service before the remembrance of the more than three-thousand Americans that died this day or the countless soldiers that have died since to avenge them.

It is a damned shame but the sad fact is that most Americans do forgot for 364 days a year. Oh New Yorker's remember. Everytime a plane flies too low or a truck backfires they remember all too well. Maybe if we fought the war here on our own soil some other people would remember too. Many then we would begin to appreciate the freedom we enjoy now if our comfortable little lives were threatened now and then. If we weren't so foolishly sure that the sun will rise for us tomorrow like it always does.

You know, that is what made the people of the World War Two generation so extraordinary. Victory in that war was never certain and all Americans had a real fear that we might actually lose that war. As a result, the people here did their best to support our soldiers by personal sacrifices and in their daily actions so that liberty could eventually prevail. No one dared to breathe a sigh of relieve until the very day of surrender, no one questioned our commitment to win, and certainly, not one person of that generation ever, ever forgot the sacrifices that were made for them.

In spite of all our faults and mistakes, may God Bless America
Paul